New Generation Vaccines for COVID-19 Based on Peptide, Viral Vector, Artificial Antigen Presenting Cell, DNA or mRNA
Department of Cell & Molecular Biology and Microbiology, Faculty of Science and Biotechnology, University of Isfahan, Isfahan, Iran
Monoclonal Antibody Research Center, Avicenna Research Institute, ACECR, Tehran, Iran, Tel: +98 21 22432020; Fax: +98 21 22432021 E-mail: Ma.firstname.lastname@example.org, email@example.com
At present, effective vaccines have been developed as the most successful approaches for preventing widespread infectious disease. The global efforts are focusing with the aim of eliminating and overcoming the Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19) and are developing vaccines from the date it was announced as a pandemic disease. In this study, PubMed, Embase, Cochrane Library, Clinicaltrial.gov, WHO reports, Science Direct, Scopus, Google Scholar, and Springer databases were searched for finding the relevant studies about the COVID-19 vaccines. This article provides an overview of multiple vaccines that have been manufactured from December 2020 up to April 2021 and also offers a perspective on their efficacy, safety, advantages, and limitations. Currently, there are several categories of COVID-19 vaccines based on Protein Subunit (PS), Inactivated Virus (IV), Virus Like Particle (VLP), Live Attenuated Virus (LAV), Viral Vector (replicating) (VVr) and Viral Vector (non-replicating) (VVnr) in progress or finalized as indicated by the WHO reporting of April 1, 2020.
SARS-CoV-2, as the third zoonotic coronavirus after SARS-CoV and MERS-CoV causes an acute respiratory disease 1,2. Because of similar structure and gene homology (75-80% to SARS-Cov, 50% to MERS-Cov) this new emergent virus was named SARS CoV-2 3. In addition, the receptor of SARS-CoV-2 spike protein to bind to a host cell is the same as the SARS-CoV spike one and is known as the Angiotensin-Converting Enzyme 2 (ACE2) 4. Virus attachment to the host cell, subsequent infection, antigen presenting and prevention of infection of the SARS CoV-2 is described in a simple schematic figure (Figure 1).
Since the SARS-Cov-2 emerged and caused a novel disease in 2019, scientists from all over the world have been on the research to overcome this pandemic. Many efforts in regard to COVID-19 vaccines started with the development of vaccines from various platforms against SARSCoV-2 infection. Different categories of the developing vaccine candidates are shown in figure 2. Most of them are based on the protein subunit specially the S-protein of SARSCoV-2 5.
These current vaccine candidates developed based on various platforms, including Inactivated Viral vaccines (IV), Live Attenuated Viral vaccines (LAV), peptide or subunit based vaccines, Virus-Like Particles (VLP), replicating viral vector vaccines, on-replicating viral vector vaccines, and DNA or mRNA-based vaccines. Two classical vaccines such as LAV and IV vaccines have high potential to elicit a protective immune response, while some limitations are associated with an infection and LAV vaccines can revert to wild type 6.
The aim of this study was to focus on the new platforms of the current vaccine candidates. New vaccine strategies based on recombinant DNA and peptide technology would have more safety and stability than the current vaccine strategies and would promise the manufacture and development of new generation of vaccines in a more predictable approach 6,7. Some of these new generation platforms of vaccines are introduced in this study and include peptide based, nucleic acid based (DNA or RNA), viral vector and artificial Antigen Presenting Cells (aAPC) based vaccines 6.
Peptide based vaccines: Peptide vaccines are designed based on a single or highly immunogenic small epitopes. Most of COVID-19 candidate vaccines were designed based on protein subunit specially using the SARS-CoV-2 spike protein (S protein) or part of it as the immunogenic antigen. The glycoprotein S consists of S1 and S2 subunits. The Receptor Binding Domain (RBD) of the S protein potentially attaches to the receptor (ACE2) of the host cell 8.
The following vaccines based on peptide subunit are conducted in clinical phase III for the prevention of COVID-19 (the registration numbers are included in table 1):
- The Full length recombinant SARS CoV-2 glycoprotein S vaccine adjuvanted with Matrix M
- The Recombinant SARS-CoV-2 vaccine (CHO Cell) in which the RBD chemically conjugates to tetanus toxoid plus adjuvant)
- The CIGB-66 vaccine based on RBD plus aluminium hydroxide adjuvant
- EpiVacCorona vaccine in which short fragments of a viral spike protein are conjugated to a large carrier protein (has just been approved and no published article could be found).
Thus, they might be advantageous due to targeting immunodominant epitopes which induce more immune responses based on neutralizing antibodies instead of larger proteins or whole inactivated virus 9; safety during production, and safely administered to immunosuppressed people 10. In addition, these vaccine candidates are not potentially infectious compared to the whole virus 8. Nonetheless, the T cell mediated immune response elicited by peptide based vaccine might be weaker in comparison to inactivated or live attenuated virus 11. Actually, adjuvants are required to enhance antigen presenting to the host immune cells and improve the vaccine efficacy especially long term protection. Other disadvantages of the peptide based vaccines include: diminished uptake by Antigen Presenting Cells (APC) because of the small size of antigens, requiring more booster doses and adjuvants causing low immunogenicity, non-eliciting cellular responses, requiring confirmation of antigen integrity and restricting production due to low scalability 10.
Viral vector vaccine: Several viral vector based vaccines are available and divided as replicating and non-replicating viral vectors including adenoviruses and poxviruses. In the non-replicating type of viral vector based vaccines, a safe virus with an attenuated state can deliver the desired antigen and trigger a protective immune response (both cell- and antibody-mediated) without any replication in host cell 12.
Furthermore, viral vectored vaccines present the desired antigens and mimic a natural infection. The current COVID-19 vaccine based on the non- replicating and replicating viral vectors are shown in tables 2 and 3, respectively. Thus, these types of vaccines can provide a potent immune response due to inducing cytokines and co-stimulatory molecules. Finally, viral vectored vaccines provide long lasting expression of target genes in vivo compared to DNA vaccines 12.
Adenoviruses as a non-replicating viral vectors are simple to produce (in 2 weeks it could be enough to treat a thousand mice and dozens of monkeys with a novel adenoviruses vaccine), easy to purify to high titer, genetically stable, easily stockpiled, relatively inexpensive, and can be delivered via aerosol, oral, intradermal, and intramuscular routes. The aerosol route is considerably applicable when targeting a respiratory virus due to eliciting protective immune responses. It is also worth noting that viral vector vaccines tend to induce a robust response in both B cells and T cells 13 with a single dose and a good safety profile 10.
Common to some vaccines, adverse effects of viral vector vaccines include fever, pneumonia, diarrhea, transient neutropenia and lymphopenia, fatigue, labored breathing, headaches, liver damage, and fasting hyperglycemia. It should be noted that rare but grave adverse side effects include Bell’s palsy, Guillain-Barre syndrome, gait disturbance, transverse myelitis, and an inflammatory condition in the spinal cord 13.
The most successful type of COVID-19 vaccine based on non-replicating viral vector is ChAdOx1-S- (AZD1222) under the brand names Covishield as mentioned in table 2 with high efficacy (76.0% following the first dose and 81.3% at the second dose) 14.
Artificial antigen-presenting cells (aAPC) vaccine: The Dendritic Cells (DCs) are the most professional and specialized APCs that can be very efficient in activating T cells 15. In situ delivery of cargo to DCs could be beneficial owing to a new standardized generation of vaccines with efficient scalability, stability, and more ability to induce humoral immune response vs. cell mediated immunity and high safety with low risk of adverse reactions through reducing the administered dose 16. However, usage of the aAPC based vaccines have been limited because the process of isolation of specific DCs in this approach is labor-intensive and expensive 17. In addition, the widespread use of aAPCs could be restricted by the fact that for definition and selection of MHC/peptide complexes identification of immunogenic antigens is required 18,19.
LV-SMENP-DC vaccine: LV-SMENP-DC vaccine is in phase 1/2 clinical trials with registration ID NCT04276896 as clinical trials.gov reported (Table 2). Lent viral synthetic minigene vaccine is based on the selected, conserved and critical antigenic protein domain of SARS-CoV-2. In this approach, the DC is modified with LVs expressing SARS-CoV-2 minigene SMENP. Finally, the antigen specific CTLs will be stimulated by LV-DC expressing the desired antigens.
Nucleic acid-based vaccines : Nucleic acid-based vaccines can be classified as DNA or mRNA based vaccines that are capable to induce both humoral and cellular immune responses, but several doses are required 6. Nucleic acid-based vaccines are likely to be the first priority of COVID-19 vaccines for entering clinical trials owing to their rapid adaptation to new emergence of virus 6. The list of current vaccines based on the nucleic acid is shown in table 4.
DNA based vaccines: DNA vaccines contain a DNA construct that codes for specific antigenic protein from a pathogen. The genetically engineered plasmid containing the DNA sequence is injected into the body and taken up by cells. Then, the antigenic protein is synthesized from the DNA construct based on the genetic code.
Like live or attenuated viruses, DNA vaccines effectively elicit both MHC-I and MHC-II pathways allowing the stimulation of the CD8+ and CD4+ T cells 20 and inducing both humoral and cell-mediated immune responses 21. Some advantages of the DNA based vaccines are efficient scalability, fast design and development, and being extremely safe 10. Additional advantages of the DNA based vaccines are introduction of a vector encoding different antigens in a single vaccine; low-cost production, and high storage stability 22,23. In addition, no infectious agent handling is required and it can also induce humoral and cellular responses 10.
In comparison to protein vaccines, DNA vaccines are considered to be low-cost vaccines. DNA vaccines can enhance stability for transportation and can be administered to immunocompromised patients 24. DNA based vaccine is known as a new successful approach, but the widespread use of DNA vaccination is limited due to its poor efficacy 25,26, and low immunogenicity and may require multiple booster doses 24. Currently, there is no nucleic acid vaccine approved. DNA vaccines require a special delivery platform 10. Despite the fact that clinical trials using DNA vaccines in humans elicit both cellular and humoral responses, these responses are often not sufficient to prompt significant clinical benefits. Consequently, DNA vaccines have only been licensed for use in veterinary medicine 21,23,27.
Nevertheless, it would be important to focus on DNA vaccine optimization and delivery, including promoter design, codon optimization, adjuvants for use in humans, use of electroporation, and prime/boost immunization for refined vaccine design 28. Regarding DNA vaccine administration, studies have shown that in vivo immune responses can be improved due to increased antigen delivery by electroporation (up to 1000-fold greater than delivery of naked DNA alone) 29. New advances have been reported in the immunization routes 30, for example the intradermal electroporation DNA delivery showed well tolerated, dose sparing and improving humoral immune responses in comparison to conventional intramuscular electroporation 31,32.
nCov vaccine as DNA based vaccine against COVID-19 is in phase 3 of clinical trials with registration ID nCov vaccine CTRI/2020/07/026352 (Table 4) and two others (CTRI/2020/07/026352; CTRI/2021/ 03/032051) are in phase 1/2 (Table 4).
mRNA based vaccine: mRNA-based vaccines are similar to DNA vaccines, except that the transcriptional stage is eliminated 6. mRNA based vaccines are beneficial in comparison with conventional vaccines (e.g. subunit, killed and live attenuated virus, as well as DNA-based vaccines) because of its high potential for low cost production with high yields of in vitro transcription, fast development and safe and repeated administration. Easy and uncomplicated formulation of mRNA into carrier molecules such as lipid nanoparticles, causes fast uptake and expression and finally enables entry of the mRNA into cells 33.
mRNA-based vaccines represent naturally immunostimulatory activity which is recognized by all cell surfaces, endosomal and cytosolic immune receptors. It also could provide adjuvant activity and thus elicit strong T and B cell immune responses 34. mRNA vaccines can be considered as highly safe vaccines because there is extremely low risk of infection or mutagenesis. mRNA based vaccines could be restricted due to difficult condition of storage and transporting and may need extremely low temperatures. mRNA vaccines exhibit instability and require storage at <−20°C 34.
High efficacy of mRNA based vaccines would be achieved owing to more stability of mRNA and high translatability through various modifications in mRNA structure. Additionally, degradation of mRNA has been normally done by cellular processes, and in vivo half-life of mRNA can be increased through these modifications 35.
It is crucial to consider that unmodified mRNA itself is considerably sensitive, rapidly degradable, and highly immunogenic with high probability of activating a variety of pathogen-associated molecular pattern sensors 34. Researchers showed that some modifications to nucleosides in mRNA molecules could improve the translatability and safety of mRNA vaccines as well as half-life 36. They reported that the incorporation of N1-methyl-pseudouridine (m1Ψ) in place of uridine increased the translatability (10-fold) over unmodified mRNA. This m1Ψ mRNA modification was included in the vaccine designing of two recently licensed mRNA vaccines mRNA-1273 and BNT162b2 37-39.
As shown in figure 3, new research by Lombardi et al showed that the BNT162b2 (Pfizer) and mRNA-1273 (MODERNA/NIH) vaccines displayed an excellent efficacy (94%) 40. Safety data of mRNA BNT162b2 and mRNA-1273 vaccines indicated that these vaccines are safe without any adverse reactions or health complications 38,39. Self-replicating RNA vaccines have high potency to express more antigens per cell and stimulate protective immune response with lower dose in comparison with classic RNA vaccines 41.
Appearance of various subtypes of SARS-COV-2 virus due to different mutations, antigenic shift and antigenic drift may allow the virus to deceive the immune system even after the administration of the vaccine and offer insights into virus evolution. Dorp et al detected 198 mutations of SARS-COV-2 from the 7500 positive samples which caused the emergence of this novel virus with genomic diversity. Therefore, it can be concluded that these 198 mutations, which originated separately may indicate the evolution of the virus within the human host 42.
Another point to consider is that, the benefits of an effective vaccine must outweigh the attributed known risks before its administration. Moreover, both safety and efficacy of the vaccine can be considered at least one year after administration. It is impossible to predict which types of candidate vaccines will be successful without running large-scale clinical trials.
In addition, the effectiveness of every vaccine, regardless of its targeting abilities, is also characterized by the dose, size, surface charge, cargo, using adjuvants, route of administration, and the species to which it is delivered.
This review has some limitations which are presented as following future directions: Future directions of the COVID-19 vaccine must consider the optimizations of the COVID-19 vaccine which are known as the durability, dose, schedule and boosters; the effectiveness of the vaccine (Real word evidence or Herd immunity); safety (long term) and also the surveillance of the new subtypes (mutants) of virus.
We would like to appreciate the Monoclonal Antibody Research Center, Avicenna Research Institute, ACECR. This work was supported by a grant number of 990204-009 from Avicenna Research Institute.
Conflict of Interest :
The authors declare no competing interests regarding this article.
Figure 1. Schematic illustration of viral vector vaccines against SARS CoV-2 and prevention of infection. Intramuscular (IM), Electroporation (EP).
Figure 2. Different categories of SARS-CoV-2 Vaccines. Source: ClinicalTrials.gov website; WHO.
Figure 3. Sinovac efficacy trials have announced efficacies (for the same product) of 50%, 65%, 78% and 91% 12,26.
Table 1. Protein subunit vaccines, curent clinical phases
Source: ClinicalTrials.gov website; WHO.
Table 2. Viral vector (non-replicating) vaccines, clinical trials. Source: ClinicalTrials.gov website; WHO
Table 3. Viral vector (replicating) vaccines, clinical trial
Source: ClinicalTrials.gov website; WHO.
Table 4. DNA or RNA based vaccines, clinical trial
Source: ClinicalTrials.gov website; Covid19.trackvaccines.org, WHO.